Futures and Pasts Festival Review in Swiss Music Mag Loop

19 October, 2026

Futures and Pasts Festival Review in Swiss Music Mag Loop

Beyond the Grave
In Manchester, they celebrated the legacy of The Fall for three days. A Swiss superfan was there—and, thanks to a bizarre catalyst made it into the Guardian’s festival report.

While all other bands lose their edge or fade away, The Fall endure and simply keep going—a mantra that sustained fans for forty years. Until it all came to a sudden end in the winter of 2018: Mark E. Smith passed away at the age of sixty from lung and kidney cancer. Because the lyricist and vocalist embodied the band, The Fall died with him. He claimed sole ownership of the group, asserting without substantiation that 'If it’s me and your grandma on the bongos, it’s The Fall.' It was him alone, a fact underscored by a ruthless turnover of musicians.

It was a shock, certainly, but after an unhealthily intense period of mourning—complete with a lengthy obituary and some lingering aftereffects—it was time to move on; a bit of distance was welcome. Watching the slow disintegration of that hard-drinking, chain-smoking wordsmith had been distressing for years, and his recent albums were no longer the eagerly awaited annual events they once were; with few exceptions, they had become strained efforts—mumbled, aching slogs or exercises in defiant posturing. After 2018, there was more time for other music—or for revisiting the early catalog. Naturally, The Fall remained—to paraphrase John Peel—the benchmark against which all other bands and their work were measured: untouchably magnificent. For me, they were and remain the only band whose songs aren't tethered to specific emotions, memories, or romances from a particular time in my life; nothing could tarnish, sully, gather dust on, or otherwise damage their body of work. That is something I cannot say even about Wire, Gang of Four, or Talking Heads.

A More Relaxed Existence
Since 2018, then, a more laid-back, relaxed kind of fandom. One viewed eager imitators like The Cool Greenhouse, Yard Act, and Bodega with, at best, the sympathetic indulgence that comes with age. One followed with greater interest the career of original Fall guitarist Martin Bramah, who kept going with his band Blue Orchids and—with Factory Star—even reunited with the longest-serving Fall bassist, Steve Hanley (a member from 1979 to 1998), and his brother Paul (Fall drummer from 1980 to 1985). Since 2023, he has been part of the group HOUSE Of ALL alongside the Hanleys, former Fall members Pete Greenway (guitar) and Simon Wolstencroft (drums), and—more recently—even Karl Burns (drums, for the third time); the band makes no secret of its 'Fall sound'. As a founding member, Bramah embodies—and endures—the essence of The Fall. 'Once The Fall, always The Fall; there is no escaping that association,' he explained.

"You can either embrace it and have fun with it, the way HOUSE Of ALL do. Or you can retreat like a hermit and disappear." That is what many of the former members interviewed in the book The Fallen did—most notably, until recently, Karl Burns. A more relaxed existence, too, for a Fall fan from Eastern Switzerland: Dipping into the early catalog (1978–85) now and then—there’s always plenty of material there—plus a trip to Glasgow for a House Of All concert: a spirited, loud, yet ambivalent affair. And then, unexpectedly, an announcement that seemed surreal: a three-day festival dedicated to The Fall—anchored to the 50th anniversary of punk (1976–2026) — taking place in Manchester on the first weekend of June? Unthinkable—indeed, sacrilege—during Mark E. Smith’s lifetime. The group’s (group, not band) absolute ruler would never have permitted an anniversary celebration, especially since he never saw himself as part of a friendly band or clique and disliked most of his fans— particularly the students and smart alecks who analyzed his surrealist lyrics down to the last detail.

Forget it — unless your grandma joins in on the drums, he seems to be scolding from my kitchen wall. That’s where M.E.S. has hung since 2018—a press photo from the 'Old Knitterface in the Pub' file; he passed away on January 24, "officially the most depressing day of the year according to psychologists and meteorologists" (as the caption reads). You flinch, then study the organizers and the program, and quickly realize: this can’t go wrong. There are no hipster poseurs, vultures, or charlatans at work here, but rather committed, qualified "Fall" devotees—insiders who have cleverly chosen the festival title: The Fall: Futures and Pasts. Borrowing from the 1979 song, the title promises everything in the plural—futures and pasts—both with and without M.E.S.

Organised by the enthusiast-run publisher Route Publishing—which has released several books on The Fall—in collaboration with Louder Than Words Festival and the Hanley brothers, the festival promises much of what the obsessive fan craves: talks and interviews featuring former members, producers (Grant Showbiz), and prominent fans such as comedian Jim Moir (aka Vic Reeves) and poet Simon Armitage; a Fall quiz (Frank Skinner); a Fall mass (Stephen G. Titley); DJ sets; and concerts by Poppycock (featuring founding Fall member Una Baines), Imperial Wax (the final incarnation of The Fall), The Look Back Bores (Fall covers), and The Fallen Women (Fall karaoke).

No guts, no regrets
So, off I go to the epicenter of my musical world: Manchester. I know nothing about the city, even though it accounts for the bulk of my music collection; the motto 'If I go, I stay for at least a month' is proving to be a silly excuse as I get older (though it makes more sense in the case of Chicago and Brisbane—other hubs of my accumulated fan-music collections). Three days before departure, an invitation arrives for festival pass holders from The Fallen Women: there are still spots left to join them for a grand finale rendition of a Fall song. This sends my nerves into a tailspin: for a whole night, I wrestle with a sudden urge to get up on stage and stutter 'Rowche Rumble' into the mic — that early track about working-class women in Northern England sedated by Roche’s Valium. Or perhaps 'Kicker Conspiracy' —voted the best of the top 20 football pop songs by The Guardian that very week—performed while hiding behind a distorted mask of Gianni Infantino... and singing in Swiss German? But then again, would I really want to be just another nameless Swiss guy doing karaoke as M.E.S. alongside the likes of Stewart Lee, Lias Saoudi (Fat White Family), Miki Berenyi (Lush), or even Brix Smith — some of the big names who had already put themselves out there for the "xx is Mark E. Smith" show? Of course, I don't have the guts to do it — and come Sunday evening, I won't regret it.

Upon arrival, I headed straight for the action at Band on the Wall — a venerable music club where The Fall loved to play just as often as other local bands (like Buzzcocks and Joy Division) that had formed in the wake of the Sex Pistols’ spark-igniting gig at Manchester’s Lesser Free Trade Hall in June 1976 ('the gig that changed the world'). The venue has since been spruced up for modern times, yet it retains enough grit to suit the post-punk aesthetic perfectly; indeed, the autumn lineup features acts like Arab Strap, A Certain Ratio, and Buffalo Tom. I picked up the small festival magazine—titled The Fall: Load o’ Bloody Nowt (Northern English for a "load of damn rubbish") — realizing that this three-day colloquium promised a lesson in dialect as well—and then immersed myself in the universe of The Fall, a realm I wouldn't leave for the next three days. I didn't even make it to the nearby record store, Piccadilly Records, where a spray-painted image of John Cooper Clarke waves from the exterior wall. The program offered such a captivating 'load of nonsense' that it took one’s breath away; I didn't want to miss a single second. Although HOUSE Of ALL were missing, the two Hanleys and other former Fall members performed under the banner 'Lost In Music' — playing the Sister Sledge hit alongside other great songs that Mark E. Smith’s group had idiosyncratically 'covered', such as The Kinks’ 'Victoria' or R. Dean Taylor’s 'There’s a Ghost in My House'. All eyes were on bassist Steve Hanley, who endured Mark E. Smith’s whims longer than any of the other sixty-plus musicians who played in the band. He also co-wrote over 100 Fall songs, including classics like 'Totally Wired', 'Container Drivers', and 'Leave The Capitol'.

Dreaming — jaw-dropped
The Look Back Bores take on these songs—favorites among the Swiss fan base here. They quickly make it clear that they don’t view themselves as a cover or tribute band, but rather as 'Fall fans playing Fall songs for Fall fans'. Yet Mark E. Smith always took pride in the fact that there was no Fall tribute band. What these 'frivolous bores' unleash on stage with two distinct vocalists — one a lanky Dadaist joker, the other a well-dressed young buck sporting a gold chain — is strikingly close to The Fall’s best live incarnations from the 1978–1990 era. "Even the wrong notes are perfect," praises Paul Hanley, the festival’s co-organiser. And the nonchalance with which these guys nail even the trickier tracks — 'The Classical' or 'Cab It Up', and finally, of course, 'Big New Prinz' with the requisite audience participation ("He is not appreciated") — is impressive; the encore, 'Blindness', leaves everyone spellbound and open-mouthed. All this, mind you, is done purely as a hobby two or three times a year in the Greater Manchester area, as singer Ben Toft tells me afterwards. At a time when bands like Sonic Youth or The Wedding Present are performing their classic albums again, why don’t European promoters book The Look Back Bores to revive The Fall’s glory days? Especially for those born too late—fans who listen to countless imitators but never got to experience the original live.

That’s the sort of stuff the Swiss guy jots down in his phone’s notes. Otherwise, there is little time to take notes; fortunately, most of the program items will be available later as podcasts or YouTube videos —perhaps even the revival of the preposterous musical Hey! Luciani, about the mysterious death of Pope John Paul I (Albino Luciani), who passed away in 1978 after just 33 days in office. Here, too, the Look Back Bores serve as the backing band, with Graham Duff directing—the man who co-wrote the screenplay for a very strange horror film (The Otherwise) with Mark E. Smith and who will share some memorable observations about his friend with the festival audience: "Mark always wrote elliptically. And apart from the Beatles, no one has invented as many characters in their lyrics as he did."

So much for repetition, repetition, repetition: "The Fall offer more variety on a single album than most bands do across their entire body of work," says Stephen G. Titley in his Hip Priest reading 'Church of The Fall', comparing Mark E. Smith to either Nelson Mandela or George Best. "He’d hit 60-meter passes and then vanish again, but he was never déjà vu." Indeed, if you want to understand The Fall, you have to do a hell of a lot of reading, according to pop culture scholar Martin Coonan; in his tongue-in-cheek lecture on the academic study of the band, he specifically acknowledges the insights of Mark Fisher.

We fans of The Fall know that this body of work is enough to last a lifetime. That is what many say, and naturally "we need this campfire", as Simon Armitage puts it. Sometimes one risks forgetting just how witty most of The Fall’s members are — especially the Hanley brothers, who could rival many TV comedians when it comes to laconic quick-wittedness. And they even channel their humor into their music: Steve Hanley — author of The Big Midweek, an insider’s account of life in the band — belts out five Fall songs on a kazoo (!) for the quiz. Frank Skinner is also dryly amusing, of course ("I played 'Lie Dream of a Casino Soul' at my wedding; my wife walk down the aisle to 'Container Drivers'…").

Festival Images

Between Pub and Clarinet
You could listen for hours to Grant Showbiz — introduced to The Fall by Mark Perry (Alternative TV) in 1978, he soon became one of their key producers. He was always at the service of the 'Fall Sound' — which Showbiz describes as "mystical, magical, weird", yet also delightfully playful. As a producer, he required considerable improvisational skill: "With any other band, I’d talk about music, but not with The Fall." His anecdotes about Mark E. Smith are incredible — from the time Smith scratched his name into The Kinks’ studio piano to driving the studio team mad with calls from his hotel, such as ordering them to turn up the guitars just as they were fine-tuning the cymbal sound. The most notorious instance occurred during the Bend Sinister sessions: Showbiz and guitarist Craig Scanlon spent hours recording a clarinet part for a song. When Smith arrived at the studio, he cursed the instrument and angrily ordered the track erased. He then went to the pub and got drunk. Three hours later, he returned and railed against the new mix: "Where’s the clarinet? That was the best thing on the whole track."

Showbiz had his own tricks: on one occasion, he had Billy Bragg record a missing fourth guitar riff — even though Bragg and Smith were such polar opposites that the universe would have exploded had they ever met. Yet Showbiz also speaks of a Mark E. much like the one his three sisters — who were present at the festival — knew: an incredibly warm, funny guy who loved people. And hugged them, too; Rough Trade boss Geoff Travis was taken aback, having never been hugged by a man before. Sadly, over the years, Smith increasingly adopted the persona of a nasty cynic and apparent misanthrope.

It is one of the most touching moments for the thoroughly entertained audience. Among the crowd — ranging from 250 people during the day to 400 in the evening — there may be some eccentric nerd types, but overall, it is a genuinely open and friendly gathering, with people mingling freely. Bonds are forged at the bar, or upstairs, where small groups marvel at an exhibition of original artwork created for The Fall’s releases — such as 'Ghost In My House' and 'Hey! Luciani' by Smith's eldest sister Suzanne, or Imperial Wax Solvent by Anthony Frost. Also on display are legendary photo series by Michael Pollard, a cross-stitch piece titled 'The Wonderful and Frightening World of The Fall' by Michelle Hickman, and a drawing by Jeffrey Lewis featuring characters from 100 Fall songs. All the artists are present — except for Lewis. Of all people, he is the one missing: New York City’s biggest Fall fan (Thurston Moore aside) and a familiar face thanks to countless guest appearances at the Palace St. Gallen.

And what does the Swiss guy — presumably the only one there — chat about outside during smoke breaks, if not the initial spark provided by The Fall? Football — that’s a safe bet in England. After all, these are the types who watch the BBC’s Final Score broadcast from November 2005 every year — the one where Mark E. Smith, a Man City fan, reads out the football results. They’ve traveled in from Bolton, Sheffield, Leeds, Norwich, or Nottingham; the guy from Rorschach ("The continent’s oldest football club, FC St. Gallen, was founded in 1879 in the town where I grew up on Lake Constance") can only learn a thing or two: Sure, any English city of even moderate size has two teams — "No, don't give us that Forest rubbish; we’re Notts County..." Switzerland comes up occasionally ("Oh yes, Kleenex/Liliput and Yello, right?"); the festival does reveal, after all, that it was during a 1983 tour of Switzerland that Smith first told his musicians about his idea for a musical. Yet no one seems to remember the concerts from back then in Biel, Zurich, or St. Gallen — not even the Hanleys, who are posing for fanboy selfies. The only thing you can get out of them is, "Oh, that was the first tour without Marc Riley." However, Steve Hill — a journalist sporting a Half Man Half Biscuit T-shirt — is interested in why a Fall fan from Switzerland would spend a rainy weekend in a Manchester music venue. Choosing a T-shirt was just as tricky as finding a room in the bustling Northern Quarter: the rain calls for shirts, yet the majority are wearing tees from various eras of The Fall — or from other favorite bands, making it easy to spot kindred spirits. The guy in the Pixies shirt tends to get avoided, though — haha.

"Not a single asshole here."
Steve Hill is soon to publish a book with Route — the first of its kind—about my second-favorite band from Northern England (none other than HMHB) and their obsessive fanbase. For his report on The Fall’s festival appearance for The Guardian, he is specifically seeking out fans from abroad: the Danes associated with the film crew behind the documentary It’s Not Repetition, It’s Discipline (2014), as well as Americans and Australians. One might have expected French, Dutch, or German fans, yet there are hardly any to be found — or at least none who stand out. Most British fans of The Fall, Hill’s article notes, "probably discovered the band through a combination of John Peel and the NME." All the more interesting, then, are the backstories of international fans like Ray from L.A. or — spare a thought for — Marcel from Switzerland, who ordered a record by a London band called The Wall but was accidentally sent The Fall’s debut album instead; that mistake sparked a lifelong passion...

In the end, it isn’t the Swiss fan whose knees are shaking, but Hill. His entry for the 'Eat Yourself Fitter' contest had been weighing on his mind for the entire three days. You feel for him, but he manages to pull off his Smith impression with The Fallen Women respectably — at one point even making a move toward the amplifier. "You can do anything—except fiddle with the amps or marry the keyboard player" — that was the rule for all would-be Smiths. While the big-name stars are absent, a number of key figures do make an appearance, including host Daryl Easlea — whom Smith always referred to simply as 'The Sleevenote Fella'. Despite Smith’s disdain for retrospectives ("It embodies a trainspotter mentality: little men collecting things"), Easlea had compiled the 2004 best-of album 50,000 Fall Fans Can’t Be Wrong, delighting even the more critical fans in the process. After a final group photo and the house lights coming up, 'Bill Is Dead' plays —a song two-thirds of Fall fans want for their own funerals — and the sting of this once-in-a-lifetime moment sets in. "I don’t want to go back to the other world," says Mojo journalist Ian Harrison at the exit. Yes, it was the perfect Fall bubble. Even the pizzas were fantastic — both at the Band on the Wall venue and at the listed hipster food hall next door; a place where even the band Tocotronic would have loved to go for "pizza with Mark E. Smith". The only one missing was Martin Bramah — reportedly because it had been 49 years since The Fall was founded, not 50.

The Fall festivities continue; September sees the release of their 32nd studio album, Post-Script, featuring nine previously unreleased songs — co-produced and promoted as the 'official farewell album' by former manager Ed Blaney. (The rest of the Fall family remains understandably skeptical.) Meanwhile, Una Baines has already announced the next Manchester festival for the first weekend of September: '50 Years of Fallen Women', dedicated to all the women who shaped The Fall — or were shaped by them. I’ll likely have to go back, hoping to finally catch Simon 'Funky Si' Wolstencroft’s exclusive city walking tour — the only event I missed because it was fully booked twice over. It’s a chance to follow the drummer as he retraces the paths of the bands he played with: The Fall, The Smiths, The Stone Roses... At the festival, it seemed no one had more friends in Manchester than he did.

Here is something else Ian said outside the Band on the Wall venue on that rainy Sunday night: "Not a single asshole here. Amazing." It really was the kind of warm, funny memorial service one hopes for from a large family. And it was that lively couple from Dublin who voiced exactly what I was feeling: "The best part is that, for all that was said and played, the mystery of The Fall remains — or has perhaps even deepened." Back home, out of some 540 Fall songs, the first one I put on was 'Psykick Dancehall'. No idea why.

Marcel Elsner

(*The text here is an English translation of the original German, approved by Marcel.)

Related Products

You Must Get Them All

You Must Get Them All

Steve Pringle

You Must Get Them All is the first book to capture the full, incredible story of The Fall, from Live At The Electric Circus to New Facts Emerge. It is a comprehensive chronology of the life and times of Britain’s most remarkable group,

Read More
Have A Bleedin Guess

Have A Bleedin Guess

Paul Hanley

The inside story on The Fall's classic album, Hex Enduction Hour

Read More
The Big Midweek: Life Inside The Fall

The Big Midweek: Life Inside The Fall

Steve Hanley, Olivia Piekarski

Steve Hanley's memoir give unprecedented insight into the intense, highly-charged creative atmosphere within The Fall and their relentless work ethic.

Read More
You Can Drum But You Can’t Hide

You Can Drum But You Can’t Hide

Simon Wolstencroft

You Can Drum But You Can’t Hide hands you an access all areas pass to the back alleys and living rooms of the musical mavericks synonymous with the city of Manchester.

Read More
Load O Bloody Nowt #2

Load O Bloody Nowt #2

Michelle Hickman

Issue No 2 of The Fall fanzine. Made in collaboration with The Women of The Fall Weekender.

Read More
Load O Bloody Nowt #1

Load O Bloody Nowt #1

Michelle Hickman

Issue No 1 of The Fall fanzine. Made in collaboration with The Futures and Pasts Festival.

Read More